Giving Thanks, Not Wire Instructions: How to Prevent Closing Fraud

A closing should feel like a finish line. It should not feel like a test of whether you can spot a fake email under pressure.

Wire fraud is built around urgency, trust, and small changes. A criminal may impersonate a seller, buyer, real estate agent, lender, or title professional. They may ask for new wire instructions, redirect seller proceeds, or create a convincing emergency.

The answer is simple, but it requires discipline: Verify Before Wire.

The Truth About Closing Fraud

Most wire fraud does not begin with a dramatic breach. It often begins with a normal conversation.

An email account may be compromised. A criminal may monitor a transaction for weeks. They learn the names of the parties, the closing date, the property address, and the language used by the professionals involved. Then they send a message that looks familiar.

The request may say:

  • “Please use these updated wire instructions.”
  • “The seller changed banks.”
  • “Send the proceeds to our company account.”
  • “The seller’s account is temporarily unavailable.”
  • “This needs to be handled before the bank closes.”
  • “Do not call. I am in a meeting.”

That last request matters. Legitimate parties do not need you to bypass verification.

The most important rule is this: A request to send seller proceeds to someone who is not an owner is a significant red flag. It does not automatically prove fraud, but it should stop the process until the request is independently reviewed, documented, and verified.

Seller proceeds belong to the seller unless there is a legitimate, properly documented reason for another arrangement. A last-minute request to send money to a contractor, relative, business partner, LLC, or other third party demands extra caution.

Why Social Engineering Works

Fraudsters do not always need advanced technology. They need information and timing.

Social engineering means manipulating people into taking an action they would normally question. The fraudster creates pressure and uses details from the real transaction to appear credible.

Common tactics include:

  • Using a look-alike email address with one extra letter or a different domain
  • Copying the tone and signature of a real participant
  • Sending messages outside regular business hours
  • Referencing a real property, loan, or closing date
  • Creating a false emergency
  • Asking for a wire change shortly before closing
  • Claiming that normal procedures will delay the transaction
  • Sending a link or attachment that appears to contain new instructions

The goal is to make you react before you think.

That is why closing security must be based on a process, not instinct. Familiar names can be impersonated. Email threads can be compromised. A professional-looking document can still contain fraudulent instructions.

The Principle: The Wire Is Never Real Until It Is Verified

At Independence Title, we believe protection starts with clear communication and disciplined follow-through.

Kevin Tacher, The Title King and Founder and CEO of Independence Title, takes a direct approach to transaction security: do not let urgency replace verification.

The wire is never real until it is verified.

That applies to the first set of instructions and every change that follows. It applies whether the request comes from a new email, a familiar email thread, a text message, or a phone call.

A wire instruction is not verified because it looks professional. It is verified when the intended recipient is contacted through a trusted channel and confirms the details independently.

This is part of a broader closing standard: Protect what matters most.

Email wire change request separated from a secure verification shield

The Fraud Prevention Playbook

1. Stop when wire instructions change

Treat every change to wire instructions as suspicious until proven otherwise.

Do not rely on the fact that the message came from an existing email thread. Do not assume the change is valid because the sender knows details about the transaction. Do not forward the message to another person and ask them to decide.

Pause the transaction and notify the title or closing team through a known phone number.

2. Use independent contact information

Never verify a wire change by replying to the same message that delivered it.

Call the title company, seller, buyer, lender, or other recipient using a phone number obtained independently. Use a number from a previously verified contact record, the company’s official website, or trusted closing documents.

Do not use the phone number inside a suspicious email. A fraudster may provide a fake number that connects directly to the scheme.

For Independence Title, start with the contact information available through the official Independence Title website.

3. Confirm the details verbally

Before a wire is sent, confirm the following:

  • The recipient’s full legal name
  • The bank name
  • The routing number
  • The account number
  • The purpose of the payment
  • Whether any recent changes were made
  • Whether the request matches the closing documents

The person receiving the call should know that the transaction is being verified. Document who confirmed the information, when the call occurred, and what was confirmed.

4. Treat third-party disbursement requests as high risk

A request to send seller proceeds to someone other than the seller requires special attention.

Examples include requests to send funds to:

  • A contractor
  • A family member
  • A business or LLC
  • A partner in an investment transaction
  • A real estate agent
  • A lender or creditor
  • An account in another person’s name

Do not treat this as a routine administrative update. Require appropriate written documentation and confirmation from the seller through a verified communication channel. The title or closing team may also need additional identity verification before considering the request.

Never let a seller proceeds request move forward solely because someone says it is urgent.

5. Confirm before and after the wire

Before sending funds, verify the instructions. After sending funds, confirm that the wire was received.

The person sending the wire should also ask the bank whether the information matches the intended beneficiary. Keep all confirmation records.

If there is any uncertainty, stop. A short delay is safer than an irreversible mistake.

Slow is smooth. Smooth is fast.

Buyer or seller verifying closing information by phone with a title professional

What Real Estate Professionals Should Tell Clients

Real estate agents, brokers, lenders, and title professionals should discuss wire fraud before the closing week.

Clients need to know:

  • Wire instructions will not be accepted without verification
  • Email is not a secure method for changing financial instructions
  • Last-minute changes are suspicious
  • The title company will not pressure them to skip established procedures
  • They should call a known number before sending funds
  • They should never send sensitive financial information through an unverified link or reply

This conversation should happen early, not after a suspicious message arrives.

Agents and brokers can also point clients to Independence Title’s educational resource, 7 Tips for Preventing Wire Fraud, and the company’s wire fraud article collection.

Security works best when every party knows the process.

If You Suspect Fraud

If you receive suspicious instructions, do not click links, open attachments, reply, or forward the message to other participants as if it were legitimate.

Instead:

  1. Stop the transaction or wire process.
  2. Call the title company using a verified number.
  3. Contact your bank if funds have already been sent.
  4. Request a wire recall or fraud review immediately.
  5. Notify the receiving bank if that information is available.
  6. Report the incident to the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center.
  7. Preserve emails, phone numbers, attachments, and transaction records.

Time matters. The sooner the bank and closing professionals are notified, the more options may be available.

The National Association of REALTORS® consumer guide also recommends calling a trusted source before wiring funds and treating last-minute changes as suspicious. The American Land Title Association’s wire fraud resources provide additional industry guidance.

STOP VERIFY CONFIRM wire fraud prevention playbook with Independence Title branding

A Safer Way to Give Thanks

Thanksgiving is a time to appreciate home, family, and the people who help us get there. A safe closing is part of that peace of mind.

Do not let a convincing email turn a successful transaction into a financial crisis. Build verification into every wire. Question every last-minute change. Pay close attention when someone asks to redirect seller proceeds to a third party.

Verify Before Wire.

At Independence Title, our goal is more than completing a transaction. It is delivering A Concierge Title Experience with careful communication, secure systems, and a team committed to worry-free closings.

Learn. Teach. Lead. Repeat.

Disclaimer

This article is provided for general educational purposes only. It is not legal, tax, financial, cybersecurity, or other professional advice. Wire fraud prevention procedures may vary by transaction, financial institution, and applicable law. Title insurance coverage depends on the specific policy language, exclusions, exceptions, and facts of the transaction. Consult the appropriate licensed professional for advice regarding your individual situation.

You Might Also Want to Read

Subscribe for News & Updates

Enter your email and be the first to know about TitleRate news and update!

Newsletter Form

Skip to content